Geosciences –
Geophysics, Seismology and Engineering

GEOPHYSICS BACKGROUND

The University of Kentucky – Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences – Geophysical Sciences Program has been conducting extensive geophysical characterizations of the PGDP and vicinity since 1992.

Dr. Ron Street, Ph.D. and graduate students Christina Langston & J.B. Harris evaluated historical geophysical data collected at the PGDP. Subsequently, they collected more than 17 km of shear wave (SH-wave) reflection data in the immediate vicinity of the PGDP in an area encompassing the TCE and 99Tc groundwater contaminant plumes (Langston, 1998).

The eventual 1998 release of the report “ACQUISITION OF SH-WAVE SEISMIC REFLECTION AND REFRACTION DATA IN THE AREA OF THE NORTHEASTWARD TRENDING CONTAMINANT PLUME AT THE PGDP” remains the single largest geophysical investigation conducted at the PGDP..

The “Langston” report identified the major structural features in bedrock underlying the PGDP along the collection lines.  Data processing and filtering capabilities of the time allowed the bedrock displacement features to be tracked upward through overlying (younger) and more recent unconsolidated materials to the approximate surface of the Region Gravel Aquifer (RGA).

Rapid advances in geophysical data collection and interpolation capabilities began in the late 1990’s and continue today.  Pre- and post-processing, filtering, new algorithms and rapid improvement of public and proprietary software allowed researchers to re-process “old” data.  Data collected during the 1998 study has been re-processed over the course of two recent geophysical investigations to provide targets for additional field data collection.

The Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences (formerly Geological Sciences) began recent geophysical investigations at the PGDP in 2005.   One M.S. thesis project, ‘Structural Features Related to PGDP Groundwater and Plumes” has been completed and a follow-up Ph.D. dissertation study has been completed ‘SH-Wave Imaging of Near Surface Controls on Contaminant Plume Migration.’

Langston (1998) geophysical study SH wave data collection lines (17km)

Project Team

Dr. Ron Street, Geological Sciences-Geophysics, University of Kentucky
Christina Langston, Ph.D. Student, Geological Sciences-Geophysics, University of Kentucky
J.B. Harris, Geological Sciences-Geophysics, University of Kentucky
Dr. Edward Woolery, Earth and Environmental Sciences- Geophysics, University of Kentucky

GEOPHYSICAL METHODS to SUPPORT SITE ACTIVITIES

University of Kentucky Earth and Environmental Science (EES) geophysical data collection and assessment thesis and dissertation projects have been instrumental in the development and application of SH-wave methods in the shallow sub-surface.  From 2003 to 2014, the projects

expanded PGDP & vicinity geophysical data coverage and successfully applied two iterations of state-of-the-art data processing methods to  define the upper and lower surfaces of the Lower Continental Deposits comprising the Regional Groundwater Aquifer (RGA).  Both projects re-processed data collected by Langston (1998) and collected additional data on focused targets.

Through the additional data collection and use of two iterations of improved analytical software the Projects: 1) correlated shallow subsurface displacement  features with the lateral extent of PGDP’s off-site Northwest and Northeast Plumes in the Regional Gravel Aquifer; 2) Utilized electrical resistivity along seismic lines to identify areas of decreased resistivity that correlate with structural features  3) Utilized electrical resistivity to identify a very shallow area of lower resistivity coincident with contaminated groundwater seep discharges in Little Bayou Creek; and 4) Applied a birefringence approach to identify ‘fast’ and ‘slow’ flow directions in the RGA material (see Al-Mayahi, 2013).

Locations of electrical resistivity survey data and additional seismic reflection survey data collected in the vicinity of the PGDP. (Blits, 2008)
The Line G1 profiles from the 2008 Blits thesis (top) was updated using a state-of-the-art integrated processing algorithm for the Al-Mayahi dissertation (2013). (Al-Mayahi, 2013)
Correlation of seismic surveys with the lateral and vertical extents of the PGDP NW Plume. (KRCEE, 2008)
Electrical Resistivity Survey Line 004 collected adjacent (Line collected @ 20’ west) to LBC Seeps. Blue area illustrates a shallow area of lower resistivity coincident with the seeps. (Blits, 2008)
Seismic Line A profile produced using a state-of-the-art integrated processing algorithm. (Al-Mayahi, 2013)

Project Team

Dr. Edward Woolery, Geophysics Professor, UK-Earth and Environmental Sciences
Cora Blits, Graduate Student, UK-Earth and Environmental Sciences – Geophysics
Ali Al-Mayahi,  Ph.D. Student, UK-Earth and Environmental Sciences – Geophysics

Project Documents

M.S. Thesis Blits, Cora A., “INTEGRATED GEOPHYSICAL IMAGING OF SUBSURFACE GEOLOGIC CONDITIONS ACROSS A CONTAMINANT PLUME, MCCRACKEN COUNTY, KENTUCKY” (2008). University of Kentucky Master’s Theses. 560. https://uknowledge.uky.edu/gradschool_theses/560
Meeting Presentation Blits, C.A., et. al., Integrated Geophysical Imagining Techniques for Detecting Neotectonic Deformation in the Fluorspar Area Fault Complex of Western Kentucky, April 2008. 42nd Annual Meeting of the North Central Section of the Geological Society of America
Meeting Presentation (KRCEE, 2008) Hampson, S.K.., Blits, C.A., & Woolery, E.W. &, Correlation of Recently Updated SH-Wave Seismic Line Interpretations to an Offsite Transect of the PGDP Northwest Plume (TCE). KRCEE Quarterly Meeting Presentation, 2008.
Meeting Presentation Hampson, S.K.. & Woolery, E.W., The Future of PGDP Geophysical & Stratigraphic Modeling. KRCEE Quarterly Meeting Presentation, 2009.
Meeting Poster SH-Wave Imaging of Potential Near-Surface Geologic Controls on Contaminant Plume Migration ― Fluorspar Area Fault Complex, Western Kentucky. Seismologic Society of America Annual Meeting(2011), University of Texas.
Dissertation Al-Mayahi, Ali Z., “SHEAR-WAVE IMAGING AND BIREFRINGENCE IN A COMPLEX NEAR-SURFACE GEOLOGICAL ENVIRONMENT” (2013). Theses and Dissertations–Earth and Environmental Sciences. 12. https://uknowledge.uky.edu/ees_etds/12
Journal Article Woolery, E. W. and Al-Mayahi, A. Shear-Wave Birefringence Measurements in Faulted Near-Surface Sediment: Fluorspar Area Fault Complex, Central United States. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America (2014),104(3):1540
Journal Article Ali Al-Mayahi, Edward W. Woolery, Fault-controlled contaminant plume migration: Inferences from SH-wave reflection and electrical resistivity experiments, Journal of Applied Geophysics, Volume 158, 2018, Pages 57-64.
Journal Article Woolery, Edward W. and Al-Mayahi, Ali, “Northeast‐Oriented Transpression Structure in the Northern New Madrid Seismic Zone: Extension of a Shear Zone across the Reelfoot Fault Stepover Arm” (2014). Earth and Environmental Sciences Faculty Publications. 2. https://uknowledge.uky.edu/ees_facpub/2 (MOVE TO CUSSO)

HOLOCENE INVESTIGATION

This Holocene Investigation was an in-depth Paleoseismic fault hazard investigation for a proposed expansion of the C-746-U landfill located at the Paducah Gaseous Diffusion Plant (PGDP), in Paducah, Kentucky. The purpose of the fault hazard investigation was to determine if Holocene-active fault displacement is present beneath the footprint of the proposed landfill expansion.

The Code of Federal Regulations (CFR), Subtitle D, Title 40, Part 258, subpart B (258.13) requires that disposal facilities (such as the C-746-U landfill and possible expansions) be located more than 200 feet from a fault that has had surface displacement within Holocene time (i.e., the past 11,000 years).

The planned expansion is located directly north of the present-day C-746-U landfill. Previous geophysical studies (Blackhawk 2003) within the PGDP site and vicinity identified possible northeast-striking faults beneath the proposed landfill expansion (Below).  Prior to this investigation the existence, locations, and ages of these inferred faults have not been confirmed through independent subsurface exploration.

The Holocene Investigation geologic assessment included (a) review of relevant geologic and geotechnical data from the site vicinity, (b) analysis of detailed aerial photography, (c) field reconnaissance of the site vicinity and other important sites of previous investigations, (d) collection and stratigraphic analysis of 86 subsurface sediment cores, (e) laboratory chronological (age-dating) analyses, and (f) preparation of this report. These activities were completed at or above the accepted standard-of-practice for geologic investigations in the mid-continent region; overall this investigation represents an effort that exceeds previous levels of investigation for site-specific fault-rupture assessments in the mid-continent.

The investigation was completed as a collaborative effort involving local, regional, and national paleoseismology subject-matter experts; William Lettis & Associates, Inc., Earth and Environmental Sciences (Geology) Department of the University of Kentucky, and the University of Chicago.

Technical peer review of the approach, methods, preliminary results and final conclusions of this study have been provided by geoscientists and paleoseismic technical experts with the Kentucky Geological Survey, the Illinois Geological Survey, the University of Memphis, the University of Illinois – Champaign, Science Applications International Corporation (SAIC), and M. Tuttle & Associates.

Based on extensive data collection and analysis followed by paleoseismic subject-matter-expert review there is NOT evidence of Holocene Displacement in the study area, i.e. displacement of materials within the last 11,000 years.  If late Quaternary displacement has occurred beneath the site, the most-recent displacement occurred following deposition of the Unnamed Intermediate Silt between approximately 53,600 and 75,500 years ago.

The Holocene Investigation Report presents the findings of a fault hazard investigation for a proposed expansion of the C-746-U landfill located at the Paducah Gaseous Diffusion Plant (PGDP), in Paducah, Kentucky.

Aerial Photo Map of PGDP Landfill Complex, Underlying Interpreted Faults (Blackhawk 2003), and Holocene Project Data Collection Points.
Seismic line profiles (Blackhawk & Woolery) from line SL-1 at the C-746-U landfill Expansion
Holocene Investigation Line Sections 1A, 1B and 1C Illustrate Scale and Exaggerated Soil Unit Contacts

Project Team

Dr. Edward Woolery, Geophysics Professor, Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Kentucky
Dr. Zhenming Wang, Seismologist and Section Head (Geological Hazards), Kentucky Geological Survey, University of Kentucky
Dr. Martitia (Tish) Tuttle – Tuttle and Associates (formerly Univ of Maryland)
Dr. Roy Van Arsdale – University of Memphis
Mr. John Nelson – Illinois Geological Survey
Dr. Leon Follmer – Illinois Geological Survey
Dr. Bill Lettis, Lettis & Assoc. / Walnut Grove, CA
Dr. John Baldwin, Lettis & Assoc. / Walnut Grove, CA
Dr. Keith Kelson, Lettis & Assoc. / Walnut Grove, CA
Robert Givler, Lettis & Assoc. / Walnut Grove, CA
Sean Sundermann, Lettis & Assoc. / Walnut Grove, CA
Ken Davis, Paducah Remediation Services
Dr. Dave Amick (SAIC-Augusta)
Mr. Marshall Davenport – Jacobs Engineering, Oak Ridge
Steve Hampson – KRCEE

Project Documents

U Landfill Project Review to PPPO Review ULF Project: Further Seismic Investigation Recommendation, April 2004
SME Supporting Report Follmer, L., Soil Stratigraphy of the C-740-U Landfill Site, October 2005
SME Supporting Report Nelson, J., Tuttle, M., and Van Arsdale, R., Determination of Holocene Displacement at the C-746-U Landfill – Project Independent Technical Review (ITR), September 2005.
Project Report INVESTIGATION OF HOLOCENE FAULTING, Proposed U-Landfill Expansion Paducah Gaseous Diffusion Plant, Paducah, Kentucky. William Lettis & Associates, Walnut Creek California, July 2006.
Report Plates and Figures INVESTIGATION OF HOLOCENE FAULTING, 2006, Project Report Figures and Plates
Symposium Poster Field Investigation of Holocene Faulting at the Proposed C-746-U Landfill, KWRRI Technical Symposium, Poster Presentation, 2007
Symposium Presentation Tuttle, M., The NMSZ & Evidence of Holocene Displacement in the Jackson Purchase Proceedings of KRCEE Technical Symposium, 2007
Professional Meeting Presentation Baldwin, John, Kelson, K., Sundermann, S., Woolery, E.W., Hampson, S., Field Investigation of Holocene Displacement at the Proposed C-746-U Landfill Expansion, Paducah Gaseous Diffusion Plant, Paducah, Kentucky, Proceedings of the 2007 KRCEE Technical Symposium.
Professional Meeting Poster Woolery, E., Kelson, K., Baldwin, J., Givler, R., Hampson, S., Site-Specific Fault Rupture Hazard Assessment – Fluorspar Area Fault Complex , Western Kentucky (PGDP), American Geophysical Union (AGU) Fall Meeting, 2008
Journal Article Woolery, E., Baldwin, J., Kelson, K., Hampson, S., Givler, R., Sundermann, S., Site-specific Fault Rupture Hazard Assessment—Fluorspar Area Fault Complex, Western Kentucky. Seismological Research Letters (2009) 80 (6): 1035–1044.

SEISMIC SCIENCES: BACKGROUND AND ISSUES

Far western Kentucky lies within the northeastern extent of the New Madrid Seismic Zone (NMSZ), an area that holds intrigue for historians, geologists, geophysicists, engineers, seismologists and paleoseismologists.  New Madrid, Missouri sits astride one of the notable great bends in the Mississippi River, Kentucky Bend.  New Madrid also marks the epicenter of

the Great New Madrid Earthquakes of 1811-12.  More than 1,000 earthquakes occurred during those 2 years with the strongest up to magnitude 8.  The ground liquefied, sand boiled to the surface, the mighty Mississippi flowed backwards and the bootheel of Kentucky, across the river from New Madrid, raised and fell depending upon where you were standing.  The largest earthquakes of 1811-12 remain the strongest earthquakes to have occurred in the continental U.S. away from plate margin subduction zones.

The PGDP and the city of Paducah are located 55+ miles northeast of New Madrid, Mo. and straddle 3 known seismic zones: the Wabash Valley Seismic Zone (WVSZ), Fluorspar Area Fault Complex (FAC or FAFC) and the NMSZ.

The FAC, which is the zone in closest proximity to the PGDP, has not been active in the last 55,000 years.  Portions of the WVSZ have been active in the last 6,000 years and the  NMSZ remains active today. PGDP’s location relative to known seismic zones prompted the 1988 installation of seismic joints in enrichment process piping to ensure system integrity in the event of modern seismic events in the region.

For public officials, engineers, seismic scientists, and local folk, intrigue may be replaced by the challenges of defining and understanding the history and occurrence of earthquakes in the region, their likelihood of recurrence, and the bedrock to surface response at given locations.  Defensible and actionable characterization of the seismic hazards and resultant risks inherent to specific locations remain a challenge for all, especially the technical and regulatory community.

Seismic features in the vicinity of the PGDP.
Seismic joints added to Enrichment Process piping in 1998 as part of seismic engineering safety measures.

Project Team

Dr. Edward Woolery – Geophysics Professor, Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Kentucky
Dr. Zhenming Wang – Seismologist and Section Head (Geological Hazards), Kentucky Geological Survey
Alice Orton – Graduate Student, Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Kentucky
Jonathan McIntyre – Kentucky Geological Survey, University of Kentucky
Cora Blits –  Graduate Student, UK-Earth and Environmental Sciences – Geophysics
Steve Hampson – KRCEE

Project Documents

Public Meeting Presentation Overview of Report “Seismic Issues for Consideration in Site Selection and Design of a Potential On-Site CERCLA Waste Disposal Facility at the Paducah Gaseous Diffusion Plant“, Presentation to PGDP Site Specific Advisory Board (SAAB), 2001.
Professional Publication Wang, Z. (compiler), 2003, Proceedings of The Kentucky NEHRP Seismic Hazards and Design Maps Workshop, November 18, 2002, Lexington, Kentucky, Kentucky Geological Survey, ser. 12, Special Publication 5, 38p.
Symposium Presentation Anderson, Cora, Observed Seismicity in the Jackson Purchase Region of Western Kentucky Between January 2003 and June 2005, Proceedings of the 2007 KRCEE Technical Symposium.
Symposium Presentation Woolery, E.W., Western Kentucky Seismicity and Neotectonics: Integrated Geophysical and Geological Solutions, Proceedings of the 2007 KRCEE Technical Symposium.
Project Brief List of Kentucky Geological Survey and UK Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences Activities Related to the Seismic Hazard Assessment at PGDP, KRCEE p21.8 2007d.
Congressional Briefing Cobb, J.C., Seismic Policy and Regulation in Western Kentucky, Kentucky Congressional Office Briefing, July 2009.
Journal Article Wang, Z., 2011, Seismic Hazard Assessment: Issues and Alternatives, Pure and Applied Geophysics, 168: 11–25
Book Chapter Wang, Z., 2014, Seismic Design in Western Kentucky: Issues and Alternatives. Seismic Hazard Design Issues in the Central United States, in Beavers, J., and Uddin, N., eds, Seismic Hazard Design Issues in the Central United States, Chapter 9, p 111-141, doi: 10.1061/9780784413203.ch09.
Professional Meeting Presentation Wang, Z., 2014, Comparison of Design Ground Motion between Coastal California and the Central United States, Proceedings of the Tenth U.S. National Conference on Earthquake Engineering Frontiers of Earthquake Engineering, July 21-25, 2014, Anchorage, Alaska (DOI: 10.4231/D3NP1WJ9K), p. 8020–8030.
Thesis Orton, A., SCIENCE AND PUBLIC POLICY OF EARTHQUAKE HAZARD MITIGATION IN THE NMSZ, M.S. Thesis, 2014 (http://uknowledge.uky.edu/ees_etds/19)
Professional Publication Orton, A., Woolery, E., and Wang, Z.W., Earthquake hazard mitigation the NMSZ (Report of Investigations 32, Series XII, Kentucky Geological Survey (KGS) Publication, 2016.
Journal Article Wang, Z., Orton, A., Wang, L., and Woolery, E.W., 2016, Seismic hazard mapping and mitigation policy development in the central United States and western China, Natural Hazards, 81: 387–404, doi:10.1007/s11069-015-2086-y.

KENTUCKY STRONG MOTION SEISMIC MONITORING NETWORK

The Kentucky Seismic and Strong Motion Monitoring Network (KSSMN) is a series of 26 monitoring stations across the Commonwealth.

KSSMN can monitor any earthquake with a magnitude 2.0 or larger within Kentucky and includes monitoring of significant blasts, mine collapses, and explosions.

Data from 12 seismic stations are continuously recorded as part of the “near” real-time monitoring system.  The system “triggers” to record events of note to be reviewed.  The real-time network utilizes the Kentucky Early Warning System (KEWS) for data transmission.

Data from remaining stations are downloaded weekly via modem (weekly) or are downloaded manually on a quarterly basis and reviewed.

KSSMN recorded numerous earthquakes since January 1, 2006. Instruments are available to rapidly begin aftershock studies for large events.

Kentucky Seismic and Strong Motion Network (KSSMN) Installation Locations. Location VSAP is located in the West Kentucky Wildlife Management Area adjacent to the PGDP.

Project Team

Dr. Edward Woolery, Geophysicist, Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Kentucky (Co-PI)
Dr. Zhenming Wang, Geological Hazards Section Head, Kentucky Geological Survey, University of Kentucky (Co-PI)
Dr. Seth Carpenter, Geologic Hazards Section, Kentucky Geological Survey, University of Kentucky
Dr. Ron Street, Associate Professor, Department of Geological Sciences (Earth and Environmental Sciences), University of Kentucky
Jonathon McIntyre, Environmental Hazards Section, Kentucky Geological Survey, University of Kentucky
Cora Anderson-Blits, Graduate Student, Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Kentucky
Steve Hampson, Associate Director, Kentucky Research Consortium for Energy and Environment (KRCEE), Center for Applied Energy Research, University of Kentucky

Project Documents

Professional Publication Wang, Z., E.W. Woolery, and B. Shi, 2003, Observed Seismicity (Earthquake Activity) in the Jackson Purchase Region of Western Kentucky: January through June 2003, Kentucky Geological Survey, ser. 12, Special Publication 6, 16p.
Project Report Woolery, E.W., Wang, Z., Seismic Velocity Measurements at Expanded Seismic Network Sites, 2006, OSTI_KRCEE8.3_2005.
Project Report Woolery, E., Wang, Z., FINAL TECHNICAL REPORT: SEISMIC VELOCITY MEASUREMENTS AT EXPANDED SEISMIC NETWORK SITES, January 2005
Professional Meeting Presentation Anderson, C., Z. Wang, and E. Woolery, Observed Seismicity in the Jackson Purchase Region of Western Kentucky between January 2003 and June 2005, The 77th Annual Meeting of the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America, Memphis, Tennessee, October 3-4, 2005.
Symposium Presentation McIntyre, J., Wang, Z., Woolery E.W., Kentucky Seismic and Strong Motion Network – Including the Central United States Seismic Observatory (CUSSO) , 2007 KRCEE-PGDP Technical Symposium, 30 October 2007.
Project Report Wang, Z. and Woolery, E.W., Operation and Maintenance of the Seismic Network in the Vicinity of the Paducah Gaseous Diffusion Plant April 2009–September 2012, Final Report, Kentucky Geological Survey Contract Report 5, Series XII, 2013.
Professional Publication Wang, Z., Woolery, E.W., and Carpenter, N.S., 2019, An update of seismic monitoring and research in the vicinity of the Paducah Gaseous Diffusion Plant: January 2013–December 2017, Kentucky Geological Survey, ser. 13, Report of Investigations 6, 19 p.
Professional Publication Wang, Z., Carpenter, N.S., and Woolery, E.W., 2020, An update of seismic monitoring and research in the vicinity of the Paducah Gaseous Diffusion Plant: January 2018–December 2019, Kentucky Geological Survey, ser. 13, Report of Investigations 12, 21 p.
Professional Publication Street, R.L., Wang, Z., Carpenter, N.S., and Woolery, E.W., 2021, The Kentucky Seismic and Strong Motion Network: History, Service, and Research, Kentucky Geological Survey, ser. 13, Special Publication 1, 18p.

CENTRAL UNITED STATES SEISMIC OBSERVATORY (CUSSO)

The Central United States Seismic Observatory (CUSSO) was installed and is monitored in collaboration with DOE, USGS, and KGS to characterize seismicity and soil column response from bedrock to ground surface in the centroid of the New Madrid Seismic Zone.

The 1900-foot deep CUSSO installation located at Sassafras Ridge, near the “bootheel” of Kentucky, is instrumented to monitor three (3) subsurface horizons.  Data collected from CUSSO will be used to refine models used by architects and engineers to design ground-motion safety features.

After 15 years of operation, CUSSO received maintenance upgrades in 2020 and 2021.  The KGS Hazards Section publishes semi-annual reports summarizing CUSSO and network data collection efforts and research findings.

CUSSO Installation at Sassafras Ridge, Kentucky.
CUSSO Stratigraphic and geophysical well log interpretations. Stratigraphic interpretation from cuttings at the well head.

Project Team

Dr. Edward Woolery, Geophysicist, Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Kentucky
Dr. Zhenming Wang, Geological Hazards Section Head, Kentucky Geological Survey, University of Kentucky
Dr. Ron Street, Associate Professor, Department of Geological Sciences (Earth and Environmental Sciences), University of Kentucky
Dr. Seth Carpenter, Geologic Hazards Section, Kentucky Geological Survey, University of Kentucky
Jonathon McIntyre, Environmental Hazards Section, Kentucky Geological Survey, University of Kentucky
Steve Hampson, Associate Director, Kentucky Research Consortium for Energy and Environment (KRCEE), Center for Applied Energy Research, University of Kentucky

Project Documents

Project Brief CUSSO_Deep_Hole_Proposal_Letter_DOE
Project Brief CUSSO Deep Hole Proposal Research Objectives, KRCEE 21.5 2005d.
Press Release Deep Hole Project (CUSSO) Press Release, KRCEE 21.2 2006.
Journal Article Wang, Z. and Woolery, E.W., Recordings from the Deepest Borehole in the New Madrid Seismic Zone, Seismological Research Letters, Volume 77, No. 2, March/April 2006.
Professional Meeting Presentation Wang, Z. and Woolery, E.W., THE CENTRAL U.S. SEISMIC OBSERVATORY: SOME PRELIMINARY RESULTS.
Professional Meeting Poster KRCEE 21.7 2006d Poster CUSSO and Network.
Press Release “Researchers complete seismic borehole in Kentucky”, American Association for the Advancement of Science, Eureka Alert, December 13, 2006.
Project Report Final Technical Report, Central United States Seismic Observatory: Phase 1 Borehole Installation, March 2008 (KRCEE 21.4 2008d ).
Professional Meeting Poster Wang, Z., Woolery, E.W. and McIntyre, J., The Central United States Seismic Observatory (Overview), October 2009.
Professional Meeting Abstract McIntyre, J., Wang, Z., Woolery., E.W., THE CENTRAL U.S. SEISMIC OBSERVATORY (CUSSO), Seismological Society of America Meeting 2010_(Abstract)
KRCEE Meeting Presentation Al Mayahi, A., Woolery, E.W., Wang, Z., CUSSO Seismic Modeling Presentation, July 2010.
Professional Meeting Presentation Wang, Z., Woolery, E.W., and Hu, C., 2012, The Central United States Seismic Observatory: Site Characterization, Proceedings of the 5th International Conference on Environmental and Engineering Geophysics, June 15-18, 2012, Changsha, China, p. 223–227.
Project Report Woolery, E.W., Wang, Z., Operation and Maintenance of the Kentucky Seismic Network in the Vicinity of PGDP February 2013_Final Report, February 2013.
Journal Article Woolery, E.W., Wang, Z., Carpenter, N. Seth, Street, R., Brengman, C., The Central United States Seismic Observatory: Site Characterization, Instrumentation, and Recordings, Seismological Research Letters, Volume 87, No. 1, January/February 2016.
Journal Article Carpenter, N.S., Wang, Z., Woolery, E.W., and Rong, M., Estimating Site Response with Recordings from Deep Boreholes and HVSR: Examples from the Mississippi Embayment of the Central United States, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America, Vol. 108, No. 3A, pp. 1199–1209, June 2018.
Current/Ongoing Project Proposal PROPOSAL to DOE – Integrated Geophysical Surveying of Seismotectonic Structure in the New Madrid Seismic Zone, Central United States, 2018.
Journal Article Wang, Z., Carpenter, N.S., and Woolery, E.W., 2019, Horizontal-to-vertical spectral ratio of S-waves and SH-wave transfer functions at the vertical seismic and strong-motion arrays in the central United States, Journal of Applied Geophysics, 160: 64–71, doi:10.1016/j.jappgeo.2018.10.017.
Professional Meeting Poster Burford, Jr., D.D., et.al., INTEGRATED SEISMIC-REFLECTION AND MICROGRAVITY IMAGING ACROSS THE SOUTHERN BOUNDARY OF THE CHARLESTON UPLIFT, NEW MADRID SEISMIC ZONE, USA, 68th Annual Meeting of the Southeastern Section of the Geological Society of America. Abstract and Poster, March 2019.

SEISMIC HAZARD AND RISK ASSESSMENT

Seismic Hazard and Risk Assessment projects included research into, development of, and recommendations for the application of seismic hazard assessment methods for the Jackson Purchase Region of western Kentucky.

Project Team

Dr. Zhenming Wang, Geological Hazards Section Head, Kentucky Geological Survey, University of Kentucky (Co-PI)
Dr. Edward Woolery, Geophysicist, Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Kentucky (Co-PI)
Dr. Seth Carpenter, Geologic Hazards Section, Kentucky Geological Survey, University of Kentucky
Dr. Baoping Shi, Postdoctoral Researcher, Kentucky Geological Survey, University of Kentucky
Alice Orton, M.S. Student, Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Kentucky
Steve Hampson, Associate Director, Kentucky Research Consortium for Energy and Environment (KRCEE), Center for Applied Energy Research, University of Kentucky

Project Documents

Workshop Presentation Woolery., E.W., SEISMIC INVESTIGATION: Earthquake Input Parameters for the PGDP Region, Workshop Presentation, JULY 2004
Professional Meeting Poster Wang, Z., Woolery, E.W., Shi, B., The Vertical Strong-Motion Stations of the Kentucky Strong Motion Network, Seismological Society of America, 2004 Eastern Section Annual Meeting, Poster Presentation, 2004 (KRCEE p11.8 2004d)
Professional Meeting Presentation Wang, Z., E.W. Woolery, B. Shi, and J. D. Kiefer, 2004, What is the Maximum Considered Earthquake Ground Motion (MCE)?, the 2004 EERI Annual Meeting, February 4-7, 2004, Los Angeles, CA.
Professional Meeting Presentation Wang, Z., E.W. Woolery, B. Shi., and J.D. Kiefer, 2004, IBC and IRC 2000 and Seismic Hazard Assessment in the Central United States: An Example of Miscommunication between the Policy-Makers and Seismologists, the 76th Annual Meeting of the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America, Blacksburg, Virginia, October 31-November 2, 2004.
Professional Meeting Presentation Wang, Z., E.W. Woolery, B. Shi, and J. D. Kiefer, 2004, Some Issues with Probabilistic Seismic Hazard Analysis in the Central and Eastern United States, the 2004 Seismological Society of America, Palm Spring, California, April 14-16, 2004.
Professional Meeting Presentation Wang, Z., 2005, Role of the Kentucky Geological Survey in Implementing IBC-2000 and IRC-2000 in Kentucky: Better Communication of Seismic Hazard and Risk, AGU 2005 Fall Meeting, San Francisco, CA., December 5-9, 2005 (invited).
Professional Meeting Presentation Wang, Z., 2005, A Clear Definition of Seismic Hazard and Risk: A Basis for Hazard and Risk Assessment, Communication, and Management, AGU 2005 Fall Meeting, San Francisco, CA., December 5-9, 2005.
Journal Article Wang, Z. and L. Ormsbee, 2005, Comparison between probabilistic seismic hazard analysis and flood frequency analysis, EOS, Trans., AGU, 86: 45, 51-52
Professional Meeting Presentation Anderson, C., Z. Wang, and E. Woolery, Observed Seismicity in the Jackson Purchase Region of Western Kentucky between January 2003 and June 2005, The 77th Annual Meeting of the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America, Memphis, Tennessee, October 3-4, 2005.
Professional Meeting Presentation Wang, Z., 2005, Seismic Hazard and Risk Assessment and Communication in the Central and Eastern United States, The 77th Annual Meeting of the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America, Memphis, Tennessee, October 3-4, 2005.
Professional Meeting Presentation Wang, Z., E.W. Woolery, D. Yuan, and L. Wang, 2005, Comparison between the Active Faults in the New Madrid Seismic Zone of the Central United States and Gansu Province in Northwestern China, the 77th Annual Meeting of the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America, Memphis, Tennessee, October 3-4, 2005.
Journal Article Wang, Z., 2005, Reply to “Comment on ‘Comparison between probabilistic seismic hazard analysis and flood frequency analysis’ by Zhenming Wang and Lindell Ormsbee” by R. M. W. Musson, EOS, Trans., AGU, 86: 354.
Journal Article Wang, Z., 2005, Reply to “Comment on ‘Comparison between probabilistic seismic hazard analysis and flood frequency analysis’ by Zhenming Wang and Lindell Ormsbee” by Thomas L Holzer, EOS, Trans., AGU, 86: 303.
Journal Article Wang, Z., B. Shi, and J. Kiefer, 2005, Comment on “How Can Seismic Hazard around the New Madrid Seismic Zone Be Similar to that in California?” by Arthur Frankel, Seismological Research Letters, 76: 472-477.
Professional Meeting Paper Wang, Z., 2006, Understanding Seismic Hazard and Risk Assessments: An Example in the New Madrid Seismic Zone of the Central United States, Proceedings of the 8th National Conference on Earthquake Engineering, April 18-22, 2006, San Francisco, CA. (KRCEE p11.1, 2006)
Journal Article Wang, Z., 2006, Probabilistic Seismic Hazard Analysis: A New Approach (submitted to the Bulletin of Seismological Society of America)
Professional Meeting Presentation Wang, Z., 2006, Seismic Safety Regulations in Western Kentucky: The Role of Geology in Public Policy, Geologic Society of America – Southeastern Section­, 55th Annual Meeting, March 23-24, 2006, Nashville, TN. (KRCEE p11.7, 2006d)
Journal Article Wang, Z., 2006, Understanding Seismic Hazard and Risk Assessments: An Example in the New Madrid Seismic Zone of the Central United States, Proceedings of the 8th National Conference on Earthquake Engineering, April 18-22, 2006, San Francisco, CA.
Project Report Wang, Z., E.W. Woolery, Preliminary Report on Seismic Hazard Assessment at Paducah Gaseous, KRCEE 11.5 2006.
Professional Meeting Presentation Cobb, J, and Z. Wang, Kentucky Seismic Hazard Mapping Issues, the USGS national seismic hazard maps, the CEUS workshop, May 9-10, 2006, Cambridge, MA.
Presentation Abstract Wang, Z., Seismic Safety Regulations in Western Kentucky: The Role of Geology in Public Policy (Presentation Abstract), Southeastern Section of the Geological Society of America, Paper No. 26-7, March 2006 
Professional Meeting Presentation Wang, Z., “Seismic Hazard and Risk in Kentucky”, Kentucky Geotechnical Engineering Group, Frankfort, Kentucky, January 10, 2006.
Book Chapter Wang, Z.,  2006, Seismic Hazard and Risk Assessment in the Intraplate Environment: The New Madrid Seismic Zone of the Central United States, GSA Book, Continental Intraplate Earthquakes: Science, Hazard, and Policy Issues. (KRCEE p11.4 2007)
Symposium Presentation KRCEE-ZW02_Probabilistic and Deterministic Seismic Hazard Assessment, KRCEE TECHNICAL SYMPOSIUM, 2007
Project Report Final Report Seismic Hazard Assessment at the PGDP, KRCEE p11.6 2007
Professional Meeting Presentation Wang, Z., Woolery E.W., Challenges in Seismic Hazard Assessment for the PGDP KRCEE Symposium, October 2007
Project Brief Wang, Z., A Short Note on Probabilistic Seismic Hazard Analysis, KRCEE p.11.2, 2007
Activities Summary (2007) Wang, Z., Woolery, E.W., KGS – Earth and Environmental Sciences Activities Related to the Seismic Hazard Assessment, KRCEE 21.8 2007d
Journal Article Wang, Z., 2008, A technical Note on Seismic Microzonation in the Central United States, Journal of Earth System Science, 117(S2): 749–756.
Professional Meeting Presentation Wang, Z., 2008, Understanding seismic hazard and risk: A gap between engineers and seismologists, Proceedings of the 14th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, October 12-17, 2008, Beijing, China, Paper No. S27-001,11 p.
Special Publication Wang, Z., and E.W. Woolery, 2008, Seismic Hazard Assessment of the Paducah Gaseous Diffusion Plant, Kentucky Geological Survey, ser. 12, Special Publication 9, 37p. Above Project Report KRCEE p11.5, 2007.
Meeting Poster Wang, Z., Extreme Ground Motion at Yucca Mountain A Statistical Result, KRCEE p11.9 2008d.
Journal Article Wang, Z., 2009, Seismic Hazard vs. Seismic Risk, Seismological Research Letters, 80: 673–674.
Journal Article Macpherson, K.A., Woolery, E.W., Wang, Z., and Liu, P., 2010, Three-Dimensional Long Period Ground  Motion Simulations in the Upper Mississippi Embayment, Seismological Research Letters, 81: 391–405.
Journal Article Wang, Z., 2010, Ground Motion for the Maximum Credible Earthquake in Kentucky, Kentucky Geological Survey, ser. 12, Report of Investigations 22, 9p.
Professional Meeting Presentation Wang, Z., 2011, Seismic Risk Assessment and Application in the Central United States, Proceedings of the GeoRisk 2011 Conference, June 26 – 28, 2011, Atlanta, GA, p. 1020–1027.
Journal Article Wang, Z., 2011, Seismic Hazard Assessment: Issues and Alternatives, Pure and Applied Geophysics, 168: 11–25.
Journal Article Wang, Z., and Cobb, J.C., 2012, A critique of probabilistic versus deterministic seismic hazard analysis with special reference to the New Madrid seismic zone, in Cox, R.T., Tuttle, M.P., Boyd, O.S., and Locat, J., eds., Recent Advances in North American Paleoseismology and Neotectonics East of the Rockies: Geological Society of America Special Paper 493, p. 259–275, doi:10.1130/2012.2493(13).
M.S. Thesis Orton, A.M., Science and Public Policy of Hazard Mitigation in the New Madrid Seismic Zone, M.S. Thesis, University of Kentucky, 2014
Journal Article Wang, Z., 2015, Predicting or Forecasting of Earthquake and the Resulting Ground Motion Hazards: A Dilemma for Earth Scientists, Seismological Research Letters, 86: 1–5.
Professional Meeting Presentation Wang, Z., 2015, the USGS National Seismic Hazard Mapping Project: Issues and Improvements, Proceedings of the ATC/USGS Seismic Hazard User-Needs Workshop, September 21-22, 2015, Menlo Park, California.
Project Report (KGS) Orton, A., Wang, Z., Woolery, E.W., Seismic Hazard Mitigation in the New Madrid Seismic Zone – Science and Public Policy, Kentucky Geological Survey Report of Investigations 32, Series XII, 2016.
Journal Article Carpenter, N.S., Wang, Z., Woolery, E.W., and Rong, M., 2018, Estimating site response with recordings from deep boreholes and HVSR: Examples from the Mississippi Embayment of the central United States, Bulletin of Seismological Society of America, 108: 1199–1209, doi:10.1785/0120170156
Journal Article Zhu, Y., Wang, Z., Carpenter, N.S., Woolery, E.W., and Haneberg, W.C., 2021, Mapping fundamental-mode site periods and amplifications from thick sediments: An example from the Jackson Purchase Region of western Kentucky, central United States, Bulletin of Seismological Society of America, 111, 1868–1884, doi:10.1785/0120200300.
Book Chapter Wang, Z., Carpenter, N.S., and Woolery, E.W., 2022, Chapter 17 – Scenario-based seismic hazard analysis and its application in the central United States, in Panza, G., Kossobokov, V. G., Laor, E. and De Vivo B., eds, Earthquake and Sustainable Infrastructure, p. 349–371, doi:10.1016/B978-0-12-823503-4.00035-X (Elsevier).

SEISMIC UPDATE REPORTS

Seismic update reporting is an ongoing annual to semi-annual project.

Reports update the status of seismic monitoring and data collection related to the PGDP, the New Madrid Seismic Zone and the Jackson Purchase Region. In general, the reports focus on seismic monitoring and data collection conducted at CUSSO & the Kentucky Seismic and Strong Motion Monitoring Network (KSSMN) including station VSAP located adjacent to the PGDP in the West Kentucky Wildlife Management Area. Developments and recommendations for the application of seismic hazard assessment methods for the Jackson Purchase Region of western Kentucky are also included in the Update Reports.

Project Team

Dr. Zhenming Wang, Geological Hazards Section Head, Kentucky Geological Survey, University of Kentucky (Co-PI)
Dr. Edward Woolery, Geophysicist, Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Kentucky (Co-PI)
Dr. Seth Carpenter, Geologic Hazards Section, Kentucky Geological Survey, University of Kentucky (Co-PI)
Steve Hampson, Associate Director, Kentucky Research Consortium for Energy and Environment (KRCEE), Center for Applied Energy Research, University of Kentucky

EXPLORE THE SITE

About

Projects

Outreach

Project
Documents

Virtual
Museum

PGDP
Multimedia

KRCEE is a collaborative effort of Kentucky universities and is administered by the University of Kentucky.